top of page

SS United States - The Forgotten Plan to Bring the Liner to Yorktown, VA.

Writer: Stanton R. Daywalt
Stanton R. Daywalt
Sep 29
5 min read

A 1973 proposal envisioned the legendary ocean liner as a floating hotel and national monument for America's Bicentennial.


In February 1973, the future of the SS United States was uncertain. More than three years had passed since the world's fastest ocean liner had been withdrawn from transatlantic service, and her owners, United States Lines, could no longer afford to operate her. Although her exterior was beginning to show signs of deterioration, the vessel remained structurally sound. She was still the largest passenger ship ever built in the United States and continued to hold the transatlantic speed record established during her maiden voyage in 1952.


The SSUS moored at NIT
The SS United States moored at the Norfolk International Pier in the 1980s. Photo by Glenn Holloway

While questions surrounded her future, a resident of York County, Virginia, was developing an ambitious proposal that would give the famous liner a new purpose. Stan Gurly, a Grafton drugstore manager, wanted to bring the SS United States to the York River and transform her into a floating hotel, tourist attraction and national monument in time for the nation's 1976 Bicentennial celebrations. His efforts became the subject of a February 18, 1973 article by Robert Graves in Newport News's The Daily Press, titled "An American Superliner Condemned to Limbo."


A new home on the York River

Gurly proposed docking the liner at the Cheatham Annex pier near Yorktown, Virginia. From this location, the vessel could become a major tourist attraction for visitors exploring the region's historic sites during the Bicentennial. By February 1973, Gurly had spent approximately 11 months gathering information and support for the project. He believed the ship could generate tourism revenue while preserving an important piece of American maritime history.


His proposal drew inspiration from the success of the RMS Queen Mary, which had been purchased by the City of Long Beach, California, and converted into a floating hotel and tourist attraction. Gurly argued that Long Beach had already demonstrated the potential economic benefits of preserving a retired ocean liner, despite the difficulties involved in acquiring and converting the British vessel. He believed Yorktown could achieve similar results with the SS United States.


Growing concerns over the ship's future

Gurly's proposal was motivated partly by concerns about what might happen if the liner remained idle. The ship had been constructed with substantial federal financial assistance, and its continued deterioration raised questions about the public investment. According to Graves's article, Gurly and other local supporters questioned whether the vessel should remain in mothballs, pass into foreign ownership or eventually be sold for scrap.


The preservation advocates viewed the ship as more than a commercial asset. They believed she represented American engineering, maritime achievement and national prestige. Gurly also questioned whether private commercial interests should be allowed to acquire the ship primarily for profit rather than preserve her historical significance. His preferred alternative was a government-supported project that would allow the public to benefit from the investment already made in the vessel.


Obstacles to the Yorktown proposal

Despite Gurly's efforts, the project faced several obstacles. State and local officials had initially been reluctant to endorse the proposal publicly. Gurly reported that he had contacted the Virginia governor's office by telephone and letter but had not secured an appointment to discuss his plans. Transportation access presented another challenge. The National Park Service had expressed concerns about using the Colonial Parkway as a major access road to the proposed attraction at Cheatham Annex.


The proposed site on the York River
Cheatham Annex and surrounding shoreline on the York River was the proposed location for the floating hotel.

Gurly disagreed with the agency's position, arguing that the parkway should be available to motorists visiting the region's historical and tourist destinations. Other critics questioned whether the federal government would ever provide the money necessary to acquire and refurbish the ship. Gurly maintained that public interest and political support would be essential to obtaining funding.


York County officials take action

By early January 1973, the proposal had achieved an important milestone. The York County Board of Supervisors endorsed a request for the federal government to conduct a feasibility study into acquiring and refurbishing the SS United States. The proposal was to be advanced through Representative Thomas N. Downing of Virginia. Under the plan, the federal government would acquire the vessel and convert her into a floating hotel at Cheatham Pier.


The Peninsula Bicentennial Action Team also invited Gurly to attend a February meeting to explain his proposal. Local organizations began expressing their support, including the Peninsula Citizens' Committee and the Peninsula Shipbuilders Association. The Shipbuilders Association indicated that it intended to support the undertaking in every possible way.


A national monument that could support itself

One of the proposal's principal arguments concerned the cost of maintaining the vessel. The Peninsula Citizens' Committee pointed out that the SS United States had become an economic liability to United States Lines. The committee was concerned that a federal purchase followed by long-term storage would merely transfer the financial burden to American taxpayers without producing any public benefit.


Its alternative was to acquire and refurbish the vessel for use as a tourist attraction. Under the proposal, the SS United States would be placed under the jurisdiction of the National Park Service and maintained as a national and cultural monument. The committee believed that hotel operations and tourism revenue could eventually cover the ship's operating expenses. It also opposed disposing of the vessel to foreign or commercial interests, emphasizing her importance to the nation's maritime heritage.


SSUS Promenade Deck

What happened to the floating hotel proposal?

The Yorktown proposal was not realized, but the idea of converting the SS United States into a floating hotel continued to attract attention. On July 19, 1976, Representative Thomas N. Downing addressed the House of Representatives in support of H.R. 13218, legislation that would permit the ship to be sold for use as a floating hotel in American waters. By then, the Maritime Administration had attempted to sell the vessel on three occasions without receiving a qualified bid.


Existing legislation restricted the sale of the ship, limiting prospective purchasers to those intending to operate her under the American flag. The proposed legislation would expand the potential market to include purchasers interested in converting her into a floating hotel. The government also wanted to preserve the ship's national defense capabilities. Conditions of sale were expected to require the preservation of her navigation and propulsion equipment, allowing her to be requisitioned during a national emergency. The congressional debate demonstrates that the floating hotel concept remained under serious consideration several years after Gurly's original proposal. Nevertheless, the proposed Yorktown attraction never materialized.


The Duck Suite

A glimpse of what might have been

The February 1973 newspaper article documents one of the early efforts to find a permanent home and new purpose for the SS United States. Gurly and his supporters envisioned a landmark attraction that would combine maritime preservation, tourism and national commemoration. Their proposal was closely connected to the upcoming Bicentennial, when millions of Americans would be celebrating the nation's history.

Had the project succeeded, the SS United States might have become a permanent fixture on Virginia's York River, welcoming visitors to a floating hotel and maritime monument. Instead, the ship's future remained uncertain, and the search for a viable preservation plan continued for decades. The Yorktown proposal remains an interesting chapter in the history of the SS United States, illustrating how efforts to preserve the vessel began long before the preservation campaigns of more recent years.


Historical source: Robert Graves, "An American Superliner Condemned to Limbo," The Daily Press, Newport News, Virginia, February 18, 1973. Additional historical reference: Congressional Record, July 19, 1976, House debate on H.R. 13218.

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page